Jump to content

anthonyl31491

501st Member[501st]
  • Posts

    26
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    anthonyl31491 got a reaction from Tentayena in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    Still working on tailoring the tunic, but all components are ready, just need to get it together and submitted. 
  2. Like
    anthonyl31491 got a reaction from bjsavage7 in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    Awesome, thanks everyone for the information!
     
     
  3. Like
    anthonyl31491 reacted to GDMorti in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    I've had a look at the original post of this thread to see the cover art you mention here, in your original post you also stated there are clear front back and side views of the uniform type you are intending to make.

    Would it be possible to have these images specifically (and the issues of the comics they appear in) to get a clear idea of what you're looking to make? Suggestions in here are being made for a new CRL regarding the ISB style closure but from the sounds, it does not appear to be the one you're looking to make?
  4. Thanks
    anthonyl31491 reacted to captsafe66 in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    We seem to be back on track here, but please, keep to Anthony's original subject.
     
    Thanks.
  5. Thanks
    anthonyl31491 reacted to rattleandburn in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    The rank bars are definitely a colorist issue, it may be intentional or it may not, but I agree it should be worn as seen in the comic and also agree that it deserves its own CRL due to the variety of differences. The rank bar color thing has been seen before, in the old comics featuring Ysanne Isard - it was featured both red over blue and blue over red, internally consistent, in separate runs, while she was stated to have the same rank. Likely a colorist issue as well, but if its internally consistent within what you're costuming from then it likely should be matched for accuracy, rather than assumed incorrect.  
     
    I just want to clarify that I am NOT intending to complain about any of your costuming plans here, i'm just talking comic differences so please don't feel i'm coming for your costume in any way, I'm just contributing to the continued discussion that evolved after your original post
     
    There is quite a lot of review put into comic art before it is colored, given text, and printed, most of the review is to the panel art itself, which is why we see debatable stuff like the rank bar colors, that's a separate person. Its definitely not hastily drawn, however, its a long thought-out process with a lot of work. Luke Ross posts quite a lot of WIP of his process of sketches, revisions, inking, more revisions, etc to his work, and his choices in line art are definitely intended.
  6. Like
    anthonyl31491 got a reaction from Tentayena in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    Like I said, I appreciate all the Information. I’m already well on the way to creating the uniform pictured in the cover art, as I perfer the realism of the cover art as opposed to the angular appearance of the hastily drawn frames. 
     
    As Hask has stated, some things are illustrated incorrectly. I agree. There is oversight by Disney, but at the same time, not everything is meticulously scrutinized, and some details are simply passed without a second glance. 
     
    Its ts all based on where the artist wants the focal point of the frame. 
  7. Like
    anthonyl31491 got a reaction from Hask in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    Like I said, I appreciate all the Information. I’m already well on the way to creating the uniform pictured in the cover art, as I perfer the realism of the cover art as opposed to the angular appearance of the hastily drawn frames. 
     
    As Hask has stated, some things are illustrated incorrectly. I agree. There is oversight by Disney, but at the same time, not everything is meticulously scrutinized, and some details are simply passed without a second glance. 
     
    Its ts all based on where the artist wants the focal point of the frame. 
  8. Like
    anthonyl31491 got a reaction from GDMorti in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    Awesome, thanks everyone for the information!
     
     
  9. Like
    anthonyl31491 got a reaction from Tentayena in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    See my questions and posts. 
     
    https://imgur.com/gallery/z8srf3T
     
    I still believe there are enough images of the details of Thrawn’s Line Officer uniform  in detail, that it is irrelevant whether or not to have the high yoke or lower yoke. (Unsure of technical terms)
     
    while the change is simple enough, the cover art is more iconic than that of the inside of the comic. The illustrations are hasty and lack much detail, where as time is spent on the cover art and less angular, more realistic artistic talent is applied. 
     
    I argue that it is the higher yoke that is most acceptable. 
     
    Let me put it this way, if I am dressed as the interior Thrawn Illustration holding up a comic book with the cover art,  appearing to be accurate, it appears that in fact I was too lazy to make the tunic appear as it does on the cover. Lol. It’s a case of irony.
     
    grand admiral Thrawn, was in fact based on cover art as well, correct? 
     
    Why not LT Thrawn too? 
     
    The realism is much more likely to recreate, on top of the fact that I’d be standing next to “real-life” valine officers from the film, wearing the same colors and a different top. It would appear odd and unprofessional.  
  10. Like
    anthonyl31491 got a reaction from Hask in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    See my questions and posts. 
     
    https://imgur.com/gallery/z8srf3T
     
    I still believe there are enough images of the details of Thrawn’s Line Officer uniform  in detail, that it is irrelevant whether or not to have the high yoke or lower yoke. (Unsure of technical terms)
     
    while the change is simple enough, the cover art is more iconic than that of the inside of the comic. The illustrations are hasty and lack much detail, where as time is spent on the cover art and less angular, more realistic artistic talent is applied. 
     
    I argue that it is the higher yoke that is most acceptable. 
     
    Let me put it this way, if I am dressed as the interior Thrawn Illustration holding up a comic book with the cover art,  appearing to be accurate, it appears that in fact I was too lazy to make the tunic appear as it does on the cover. Lol. It’s a case of irony.
     
    grand admiral Thrawn, was in fact based on cover art as well, correct? 
     
    Why not LT Thrawn too? 
     
    The realism is much more likely to recreate, on top of the fact that I’d be standing next to “real-life” valine officers from the film, wearing the same colors and a different top. It would appear odd and unprofessional.  
  11. Like
    anthonyl31491 got a reaction from Hask in Lieutenant Thrawn   
    My thoughts exactly! 
×
×
  • Create New...