fil5117
-
Posts
1,603 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
50
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Gallery
Posts posted by fil5117
-
-
if you check out the UK eBay there are some dosimeters (the found part for code cylinders) there at the moment which aren't quite accurate enough, but do have the correct style clip. Which is sprung and really does the job.
-
-
Chris,I apologise for the inconsistency of the clearance process. I've been looking at the clearance levels and recently sat down to put into words as to what distinguishes the levels of clearance. I have had conversations with people (501st members) who believe there should only be one level of clearance. I'm against this and am a firm believer in the levels system. It allows people to work up towards the ideal costume image we should all strive towards. Usually accuracy goes hand in hand with cost. Having the levels will then give the option for people on a smaller budget to be included.I believe the distinction between executor and imperator should be aesthetics and accuracy. Executor should concentrate with the fitting of the uniform, what looks good. Imperator should add more accuracy, with a steady progression between the two.I am now trying to identify parts that sit nicely in this middle ground, e.g. Soviet boots and these jack boots. Previously I have been more lenient with the Imperator level, judging items against the CRL. With the problems with product availability I'm trying to be more considerate at Executor level, and conversely a little stricter at Imperator level. It's a tough line to walk, I don't want to dilute either of the standards, and I don't want to exclude or alienate people either.Unfortunately you 'fell foul' of my renewed approach. I have always maintained the uniform suits you well and you really look the part. I've googled the German eBay and they have new EU size 48 boots - US size 13).We are always trying to improve and revise our standards, what has previously cleared met the standards at the time.Phil
-
Chris,
Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, after discussing it with the rest of the command staff we believe the boots aren't quite accurate enough for Imperator level. Whilst they have all of the necessary elements, and look good with the rest of the uniform, the V section means doesn't match the look of the vintage Knobelbecher boots.
After briefly asking around, I'd recommend checking out the German version of eBay, or giving a shout out to the German 501st Garrison to see if they can help you.
Phil
-
Request acknowledged
-
Yes, it still meets the clearance requirements.
Thank you for improving the accuracy of the colour.
-
Whilst the quality of the holster is good, it has stiff leather and is formed around the blaster, the colour isn't quite accurate. It meets the clearance requirements, but ideally the colour could be a chestnut brown colour to match the ones seen in the film, e.g. Pol Tredium or Malcolm Weaver.
-
-
To be honest I thought the tunic seemed a little long. But I wanted to have a look at the films again, before I said anything.
I'm seeing Clothears this weekend to get measured up for my new line officer, I'm glad you mentioned yours is ANH styling as that's good to know.
Bit of advice for the Executor clearance, ensure the uniform is nicely pressed and make sure you're standing to attention. As silly as it sounds it makes a world of difference, and it's good practice
-
Thanks for asking the question, I've been meaning to put something to on 'paper'
-
We, the command staff, have discussed the Soviet Boots and have come to a decision.
Whilst they do not meet the requirements for Imperator Standard, the leather is too supple and their look and styling isn't consistent with English riding or equestrian boots. We have agreed they do look better than PVC riding boots that people traditional use for base clearance. As such we think they sit nicely in the Executor level - a marked improvement on PVC, but not up to the standard of English or equestrian riding boots, as seen in the films.
- Maulevolent, Qwirk and BensID39999
-
3
-
Image embedded for ease of viewing
-
David,
Thanks for your Executor submission request. On the whole you look to have a nice uniform there.
One thing that will need a little attention is the hook and eye closure on the collar. Can you please move the fasteners so they are not visible. It's interesting this is the second example I've seen this, I wonder if this is a now a common problem with the CosplaySky uniforms.
Whilst not mentioned in the CRL, this is one of the first caps I haven't seen without the detail at all. So I'd like to mention it. The higher end caps have piping on the upper peaks of the cap. Other caps mimic this with stitching. This detail appears to be missing from yours.
I'm going to ask BJ and Mark for a second opinion on the boots. Whilst they don't meet the requirements for Imperator status, as the leather is softer and doesn't match the distinctive look of English riding boots, I'll check to see if they meet the requirements of Executor. Sadly I'm not a fan of them, but I have the luxury of living in a country where the correct boot is more freely available. I think now would be a good time, to make a formal ruling on these.
Your jodhpurs don't look quite symmetrical, I can see your left flare has folded over a little. This is usually a sign of the flares being just a little too big. Also you trousers may be a little baggy in the leg.
The facial hair? Maybe the 'fuzz' on the bottom of the goatee could be trimmed a little closer and tidier for trooping, but it's not too bad.
As I say, on the whole a nicely turned out uniform. Hopefully the points I've highlighted should be easy to remedy.
Good luck,
Phil
-
Request acknowledged
-
This question is more suited the UK Garrison forum. Each Garrison has slightly different 'house rules' by the book for the UK Garrison, as I understand it, you should not troop with configurations or alterations to the costume which haven't been cleared. Furthermore in the UK Garrison we only troop with cannon costume configurations (e.g. we do not allow custom pauldrons on our Sand troopers).
-
I see part of my role as to try and inspire and guide people in to producing costumes to high a level of accuracy.
I don't penialise people who don't wish to go that far, it's not everyone's cup of tea. I see it as encouraging not alienating.
-
As I stated above it meets the clearance requirements, this is why I have and will clear lighter brown holsters. Executor and Imperator clearance requests are judged on the costume as a whole. If asked for advice prior to the submission I will give a moon on a stick answer, if I don't how can you aspire to greatness?
What I am saying is if you want to go that little bit extra, above the requirements outlined in the CRL, it would be great if you could get / dye the holster a chestnut brown colour to match the colour of the holsters worn by officers in the film, e.g. the gantry officers Pol (TK421 why aren't you at your post?) Tredium and Malcolm Weaver.
What i like to see is people going that extra mile, it's things like that that inspire people to up their game. And that's the point of Executor and Imperator to up your game and get a top notch uniform that could be mistaken for one in the film?
I was the first person to clear at Imperator level with the Fahrenheit 451 uniform, since then I know of at least 5 people (4 UKG and 1 Russian Oupost) who were inspired by this, and constructed their own uniform is this more accurate styling.
At the end of the day, our uniforms are not screen used, we aren't clones of Peter Cushing, but we can try and do the best we can to give that illusion.
-
Whilst the quality of the holster is good, it has stiff leather and is formed around the blaster, the colour isn't quite accurate. It meets th clearance requirements, but ideally the colour could be a chestnut brown colour to match the ones seen in the film, e.g. Pol Tredium or Malcolm Weaver.
-
No worries, it happens, we're here when you're ready
-
Over hauling mine, getting a more accurate Officer uniform and repairing/tweaking my armour to meet level 3 standards.
-
-
I'd advise you to have the elastic as much to the front of your foot as possible. That way when you put your boot on it doesn't ping off straight away (speaking for experience).
As Kris says make sure you register on the 501st UK Garrison forum, if you haven't already. Introduce yourself and explain which uniform you plan to do. They should be able to help you. You can also have a look at the Officer work in progress thread there to see the standard of uniforms and it may give you some more insight into the costume, even some insight into things to be aware of.
Good luck.
- Hask and Bulldog1653
-
2
-
Chris,
I wouldn't get discouraged, I'd think of level 2 and 3 as an aspiration. They're optional refinements to your costume. I started off with the cheaper riding boots, then purchased a second hand pair of leather boots.
I suppose there's no harm in attempting to modify chalk holders. Whilst level 1 clearance will get past the 'untrained eye' level 2 and 3 strives more towards replicating exactly what you see on screen, and trained eyes.
Here's the detail you're trying to replicate for dosimeters:
Phil
-
Thubin,
It's great to hear you're aspiring for level 2/3 clearance off the bat. If you do your research and take your time you can assemble a great uniform without needing to replace any of the parts, saving money in the long run.
1) With regards to the generic uniforms and in your case the Staff Officer. The uniform configuration has to match a uniform configuration from Star Wars : A New Hope.
Facial hair does matter, it has been discussed numerous times on the forum. The quick answer is:
clean shaven is best
a Yularen / Ozzel style moustache is good
a neatly trimmed beard is acceptable
a dwarven beard is not acceptable
At level three you're trying to look like you were actually in the film, you're trying to replicate the look of the officers you see on screen. A number of people grow their sideburns in a seventies style to add more depth to their costume.
2) Those boots aren't ideal. We judge uniforms on a case by case basis, and the overall appearance counts for a lot, we have made exceptions and cleared soviet boots in the past, but this is rare and they're not recommended. English riding boots have a distinctive look, the leather is rigid - the ones in your picture appear too soft.
I recommend having a look at our costume resource list:
http://www.imperialofficer.com/forum/index.php?/topic/1817-ioc-costume-resource-list/
Maybe you can find something in your budget. I purchased my leather boots from the UK eBay if you persevere you should get lucky and find some for a reasonable price (it took me a couple of months
).3) Chalk holders are not permitted for level 2 clearance. The CRL clearly states 'Only real or replica dosimeters'. Again have a look on the resource list, personally I would recommend the ones produced by ID6187.
Hope this helps.
Extra sizing holes in belt?
in Costume Questions - Ask Here!
Posted
A number of Officers in the films have holes in their belts. For higher level clearance when emulating a specific officer I would encourage a costumer to copy the number of belt holes the officer had in the film. Though, from what I can tell that uniform appears to be a 181st Officer. Do 181st Officer have belt holes in the comic? I don't know off hand. But I do have the comics at home.
I'd say generically you should allow it, on the grounds some officers do in the film, but on the whole it's not a good look.
You could also discourage it, from an accuracy perspective, if it proved the 181st Officers in the comics didn't have holes in their belts (which I'd imagine to be the case).