Jump to content

Alay

Administrators[StaffAdmin]
  • Posts

    669
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    30

Posts posted by Alay

  1. The Cartoon and Live Action CRLs are separated.  I believe Yellow is excluded on the live-action non-saga until we see a non-saga ISB Officer in live action with one.

     

    That said, if you really want to wear one at a troop, just ask your GML.  They'll likely be fine with it.

  2. 20 hours ago, kman said:

    For now, though, I'm keeping this simple, with the first two items I initially mentioned, and a requirement for Andor-style boxes at L3 (if present at all... don't forget they're optional).  We can further adjust next round, if needed.

     

    I think we need to further this discussion for next round.  Both the gunmetal call out, the pill call out only at level 3.

     

    Also do we see any attendants without them?  I haven't combed the episodes

  3. Maybe I look at them too often, but I can easily tell the difference from 15 feet away. 

     

    I think if we're breaking chops over leather belt grooves and dyed edges it should easily be a level 2-3 requirement.  I'd also merge the requirements into one, listing the wrong CRL item on an unseen costume was a big taboo for other costumes in the past.

  4. Like @kman said, notched only on OT hats.

     

    I'm curious if unnotched ones were from the original turn table, or were a different part made up extra (which is why they miss the notch... it's annoying to add if they're making new ones).

  5. Sorry it wasn't officially stated anywhere in the post so I may have missed it, but we're adding edge dyed/undyed status to CRL level requirements?

     

    Grooves I get, they're very visible, but edge dying is kind of an overly accurate detail level, especially with ESB and ROTJ showing dye mixes.  Heck I do leather work and even I can't tell the difference when I see costumers in person.

     

    I mean if we're gonna get to that level we may as well start requiring stitch holes in badges and internal snap placement and stuff like that, which I think is a little beyond the spirit of even level 3.

  6. There are several tunic and pants makers.  My biggest suggestion is Clothears costumes.  They're top notch and tailored to size.

     

    Dunno novos and Wampawear both sell off the shelf sizes.  I don't love the wampawear hat personally, but they both run less expensive than a tailored set.

     

    I'd advise against Cosplaysky, the cheapest option, as their green is very incorrect and the hat isn't correct.

     

    For boots, I've several pairs of heasen antique and love them.  You can also try to get lucky with eBay.

     

    Badge, belt boxes, code cylinders, and belts--my wife and I co-run Bailey Builds ( ezrabaileybuilds.com or clicky link in signature) where we hand make all of that stuff to the highest accuracy.

  7. On 11/30/2023 at 1:11 AM, bennroe said:

    I'm also on the hunt for a synthetic leather 2" officer belt with the incisions along the top and bottom edges. I have a good buckle already, though I'm open to getting another buckle if someone knows of a "total package" option.

     

    Why synthetic?  Real leather will hold up better.

     

    If it's for vegan reasons, plastic is much much much worse for the environment; check out Cactus leather or similar as a vegan option instead.  You'll have to diy but making a black belt isn't too tough.

  8. 1 hour ago, Riva said:

    But I won't put it into the draft CRL since there's no solid evidence, just speculation. And I wish that our CRL promote re-usability across similar characters instead of specification to one single character. After all, no two leaves are exactly the same in the world.

     

    I concur firmly; that's a little too much for a CRL (even level 2+)

  9. On 10/8/2023 at 12:08 AM, Riva said:

    Wait, after comparation, Thrawn's rank plate should be align with OT/Mando standard, instead of RO/Solo/Andor standard. I'll copy some wording from Tarkin CRL instead.

    ThrawnRankBarCompare1.jpg.87967fbf3ace8c100c06ce7ce3bb75f6.jpg

     

     

     

    Very good eye!  They looked Anthology sized on screen to me but after pixel counting with a known height, they are indeed approx 18.4mm which aligns to original trilogy sizes!

×
×
  • Create New...