Jump to content

Exaldear

Member
  • Posts

    728
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Posts posted by Exaldear

  1. 9 hours ago, kman said:

    ^^ Exactly.

     

    The precise meaning behind the "random" rank bars isn't really important, as long as we're wearing a representation of something that was actually on screen.

     

    For our costumes I agree. I was more focused on the in universe canon explanation, cause I love those little bits of lore.

  2. 5 hours ago, skelitor120 said:

     

    I feel like our determination for rank bars should be a lot less specific, then. Something along the lines of "Only these colors, only in this pattern, and you can only have this many squares" but otherwise leave the combination up to the costumer? 

    In this case I disagree. I prefer doing it off known rank bars/code cylinders

  3. I have been trying to come up with a logical in universe reason as to the difference in rank between Rebels, Rogue One, A New Hope, etc.

     

    I would love to hear your thoughts, be nice if Pablo Hidalgo could help explain.

     

    Anyway. Let's start with Rebels. So the first reason why this I feel differs from, say A New Hope is that the Empire is in a transition faze, it is not quite ANH but it has clearly thrown off the Republic, like a butterfly cocooned and forming inside. The second part is that the Empire is not actually at war yet. Yes, they are putting down Rebellions etc (or trying to), but at this stage there is no Rebel alliance, just individual cells, factions, tribes, call them what you will. In this we have seen Admirals in Black with odd ranks bars. This brings me to part two

     

    The different parts of the military machine. Just like the air force, navy, army, here have ranks with the same name, there symbol (sorry, not a military man) look different. I feel this could help explain why we have Admirals with different looking ranks etc. The Admiral in Rebels with the four yellow/amber tiles and two red (I think his name is Titus). He was in charge of the interdictor programme, therefore he may not be Navy, or he may be part of the Special Weapons Group and therefore the ranking is different. Same with the Army and Navy. I believe this is why we have odd looking rank bars in Rogue One. I think these are Army officers, not Naval.

     

    Finally. In Empire, we see a more Uniform appearance of Rank. I believe that this would be due to the fact that the Empure is now officially at war with the Rebel Alliance, and with it being (six?) Years after A New Hope. The Empire has got everything running smoothly (or close to it) is now fully out of its transition periods (yes plural) and it shows.

     

    Anyway. Would love to hear your thoughts on this. Your theories etc.

  4. So Krennic, Galen and one other officer have extended collars. Three clasps instead of the normal two you get with cosplaysky uniforms.

     

    Is there anyone who can talk to Cosplaysky and discuss their Krennic uniform, bringing it more in line with their other uniforms?

  5. 3 hours ago, Vanedor said:

    Well, technically, even Thrawn was a humanoid.

    A non humanoid officer would be something like a hutt or other aliens who don't have two hands, one head, two legs, etc. But of course, I'm not sure that's what the OP refers to :wink:

    However there is one known non humanoid in the science group. Multi tentacled (like the bounty hunter in The Clone Wars cartoon).

  6. 2 hours ago, Mkjava said:

     

    After looking at that Director Krennic 'costume' from CPS a little more closely, I think this may be more of a Halloween costume quality vs. 501st Uniform quality.  I don't believe the material is gabardine and that rank bar patch is pretty sad.  I'm going to follow Dimentex' advice and order a deluxe staff officer tunic in white using custom measurements.  I ordered my current officer uniform from them this way and I'm very pleased with it, it has served me well.  Now I need a good source for the cloak!

    That is what I meant. The deluxe is on sale (or was last time I checked)

×
×
  • Create New...